A Comprehensive Guide for Choosing the Best Grill Mat

The grill mat is an essential accessory for the best grilling experience. It provides a wide range of crystal-clear benefits that few alternatives can compare.

However, there is a myriad of grill mats on the market. Which one is the best, and how can you choose the most suitable one? Well, we understand your concerns because we have been through that situation. After a while experimenting with some top products, we finally compiled this list and found the best grill mat.

Let’s scroll down now!


What Is A Grill Mat?

To put it simply, a grill mat is a mat that lies on the grill grates to prevent the food from exposing directly to the flames.

Why can such a thin mat withstand high temps? Glad you asked!

The mat is made of fiberglass coated in one or more layers of PTFE. Hmmm, what is PTFE anyway? PTFE, also known as polytetrafluoroethylene, is a non-flammable, non-reactive synthetic resin.

Thanks to such a combination, the grill mat is lightweight, durable, and highly resistant to fires and flames.

Comparison Tables of Top 3 Best Grill Mats

Incredible Benefits of the Grill Mats

best grill mat for deck

At a glance, the first and foremost advantage of a grill mat is the prevention of burnt meat and food slipping through the racks. Plus, you will have a flat surface to cook anything that cannot stay on a grill properly.

It does not stop there!

If you always have a headache over flare-ups while grilling meat, then the grill mat is your best bet. The accessory not only prevents flare-ups but also retains the juices of the food.

Some may wonder, instead of paying money for a mat, why don’t you just close the lid? Isn’t it the quickest way?

Well, perhaps shutting the lid is the quickest method, but obviously not the best one. Once you close the lid, you cannot know what is happening inside. Imagine you open the device to find out all the burgers have turned into lumps of charcoal. That’s a nightmare for food lovers and grillers.

Flexibility is another outstanding benefit of a grill mat. Feel free to cook anything on the mat, from loose vegetables to pancakes and eggs. You see, the topper is the perfect alternative to a skillet or frying pan.

This grilling accessory is a must-have if you frequent outdoor events where you have to use public barbecues. Take the hygiene as the number one priority and purchase a grill mat to keep your food protected from unwanted residue now.

Our Choices for Top 8 Best Grill Mats

Grillaholics Grill Mat – The Best Grill Mat on the Market

This is the set of two heavy-duty BBQ mats from Grillaholics. Technically, the features remain the same as their other high-quality grilling accessories on the market. The best thing customers will get is undoubtedly the lifetime replacement guarantee from the manufacturer. With this policy, two mats are all the items you ever need for BBQ parties.

You will have two mats made of premium heat-resistant material coated with PTFE fiberglass. The safe operating temp of these toppers reaches up to 500 Fahrenheit degrees.

I bet anyone responsible for the washing up would love to have this Grillaholics product. It is BPA-free and non-stick, thereby making cleanup effortless. You can hand-wash the mat or simply put it into the dishwasher after grilling.

The mat works like a charm with any barbecue equipment, from smoker, charcoal, gas to electric grill. Plus, you can trim it to any size to fit anything you want. Isn’t it amazing?

If you still hesitate, we got one fact to convince you here: these Grillaholics mats are the only accessories to be recommended by Rachael Ray and Chris Kimball, two top celebrity chefs in the US. Ready to make an order?

  • Lifetime replacement guarantee
  • Versatility
  • Top Chef approved
  • Almost nothing significant

Verdict: With the unbeatable quality, Grillaholics grill mats pride themselves on being highly recommended by top celebrity chefs in the USA.

Twisted Chef BBQ Grill Mats – The Easiest to Clean Grill Mats

What you will get with this set of three grilling mats from Twisted Chef. Quality, of course!

These mats promise to prevent any food from falling through the grates, from burgers, meat to even fish and veggies. What’s more? You can also add some sauces, and still, nothing will drip through or cause a flare-up. Let’s change your diet for the positive now!

The design is what you can expect from high-quality, grilling accessories. The mats are well-designed with PFOA-free and PTFE coating. Plus, it is claimed as 100% non-stick. No greases or stains allowed on the surface!

What we love is the fast clean up process since you only need to wipe the mats using a damp cloth after each use. Too busy for that? Then throw them on the top shelf of the dishwasher, and you are good to go.

If you want a savory party packed with mouth-watering dishes, these grill mats are your best bet. They allow you to cook like an expert, for example, cooking juicy bacon and moist chicken to die for. Let’s take your culinary skills to the next level with this Twisted Chef product by your side.

We found cooking beef on the mat a bit hard, but of course, this is not a big deal.

  • Effortless cleanup
  • No wasted food
  • No flare-ups or high flames
  • Not ideal for beef

Verdict: One of the top 3 best grill mats today - the Twisted Chef products promise that will take your grilling skills to the next level.

Kona Best BBQ Grill Mat – The Only Mat with the Peak Temperature Of 600 Fahrenheit

KONA is one of the most respected and popular names in the grilling industry, and the product I am going to write about is the best in the brand’s lineup. First off, it is the only mat with the peak temp of 600 Fahrenheit degrees, which few competitors can beat.

Also, you will get the optimal thickness of 0.39mm, which is four times thicker than Yoshi grill mat and two times thicker than Miracle mat. We do not state “thicker is better,” but 0.39 is just the right measurement.

Another overt advantage of this product is a long-lasting life expectancy. You can use each of the mats 1,000 times per side, which is 50 times more than an ordinary mat. Now you understand what makes the huge fan club of this Kona set of two grill mats.

We think there is no need to talk about the maximum ease of use and versatility of these grill mats. Nothing but the best, you know.

Kona is so confident of the products that it provides a 7-year guarantee, which covers every defect, even damages caused by accidental overheating.

  • 7-year guarantee
  • Optimal thickness
  • Long-lasting lifespan
  • Unhelpful website

Verdict: The only mat with the peak temperature of 600 Fahrenheit degrees - Kona grilling accessories are undoubtedly your best bet.

YRYM HT Grill Mats – The Grill Mat with the Best Water-Repellent Feature

These grill mats can fulfill any purpose, whether you want to cook, bake, or grill anything with it. Also, feel free to trim it to any size to fit into your oven, stove, cake tin, pan, etc. The versatility you get with these durable mats is unlimited.

I would give this product five stars had it not been for the fact that it was a bit hard to clean. Although the grease and stains are reduced to the minimum, you still need to scrub a lot to remove anything stuck on the surface.

We stated that smooth mats have the edge over textured ones in terms of non-stick feature in the buying guide, and unfortunately, these mats come with the grid pattern.

  • Affordable price
  • Water-repellent features
  • Extreme versatility
  • Grid pattern

Verdict: The water-repellent feature is a notable advantage that few competitors can compare to the grill mats of YRYM HT.

Copper Non-Stick BBQ Grill Mat – The Best Versatile Grill Mat

You will receive a set of five extra-thick and ultra-slick mats when you order this Chefmos product. The mat measures 1.94 oz. per sheet, which is tougher compared to most grill toppers on the market.

Versatility is what we greatly appreciate from this grilling accessory. You can cook different food, including chopped vegetables, seafood, and even breakfast food like sausages. What’s more, you can use the mat with any device you have, such as a gas grill or pellet and electric grill. Even the charcoal grill is fine, too!

The mat is incredibly lightweight, which you can roll up and bring to outdoor picnics with ease. If you often hold a BBQ party outside, this Chef Caron mat is worth your investment.

I must state that the word “copper” refers to the colors of the mat instead of the material. This is not a deal-breaker for us, especially if you consider the crystal-clear benefits the mat offers.

We bet the one-year guarantee will give you peace of mind when making an order. Still not convinced? Register on the website for more extended warranty.

  • Maximum versatility
  • Lightweight
  • Fully refund guarantee
  • Optimal measurement
  • Not copper

Verdict: With the optimal measurement and ultimate flexibility, this Chefmos mat is the best bet for any BBQ enthusiasts out there.

SMAID Grill Mat Non-stick BBQ Grill Baking Mats – The Most Durable Grill Mats

This is definitely the long-term investment you should make: buy this SMAID set of four and say goodbye to buying other grill mats for good. Is it worth your money?

Of course, yes. Each of the mats measures 15.75x13 inch, and the thickness is optimal for the best experience. I cannot find the exact figure, though. However, we tested and confirmed the quality of the mat. Both grill marks and heat resistance are guaranteed thanks to the ideal thickness.

In terms of the material, these BBQ mats of SMAID are entirely made of PFOA-free materials and premium non-stick coating. Too many scientific terms here? Well, in layman terms, users can expect the mats to last for years with proper maintenance.

On top of that, it is obvious that the non-stick surface will prevent food from sticking to the mat. But the ultimate goal behind this feature is to improve the taste and protect the health of your family. Make sure what you take in is flavorful pieces of meat, not burned ones.

However, be aware that the non-stick coating is not really durable. Particular food such as fish tends to stick to the mat after a while in use, which makes clean up time-consuming and challenging.

You may also like

  • Moderately-priced
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Ultimate durability
  • Short-lived non-stick coating

Verdict: Apart from the short-lived coating, these mats of SMAID are still worth your money in terms of quality.

LauKingdom Grill Mat Set of 5 – The Reversible Grill Mats

Do not settle for low-quality BBQ mats just because you are on a tight budget – let this durable LauKingdom set of five help you! This grilling accessory is made of 100% non-stick, and PFOA-free material. Rest assured about the quality of the mats.

While thin mats tend to crack or release harmful chemicals after a while, these LauKingdom mats are built to handle up to 500 Fahrenheit degrees for a long time. Still, it keeps the clear grill marks on your meat to enhance the flavor and the inviting look.

There is no need to store piles of mats at home once you have this set of BBQ accessories. It is because these mats are totally reversible and reusable. It is advertised that you can use both sides of the mats for over 1000 times!

It is nothing but child’s play to use the mat. Let’s preheat your grill for about 5 minutes, then keep the heat at medium level and place the topper on the grate.

More notably, the grilling mat works on a variety of devices, from charcoal, propane, gas, to electric ones. Whatever equipment you use for grilling at home, you can buy a grill mat for better grilling experience.

  • Built to last
  • Reversible and reusable
  • User-friendly

Verdict: This LauKingdom set of five grill mats will not let you down by any means.

Aoocan Grill Mat – Heavy Duty BBQ Grill Mats

Similar to the YRYM HT product, you will receive a set of five heavy-duty items once you order the mats from Aoocan. It can withstand up to 500 Fahrenheit degrees, the maximum rating according to FDA thanks to the advanced heat-resistant technology.

The brand cuts no corners in the manufacturing process. With the 100% PFOA-free materials and PTFE fiberglass coating, you will have a durable set of mats that can last for years.

The item meets security assurances, including FDA and LFGB food-grade certification. It means the mats will make your diet healthier, thereby improving the overall health of you and your family members.

You can make use of these grilling accessories to grill anything you want as nothing can fall through the grates! Plus, unlike the YRYM HT product, the surface of this Aoocan mat is smooth. Therefore, you will find washing the mats after each use effortless and time-saving. When you finish the BBQ party, simply wipe the mat with clean water and dry it under the sun.

One word of caution is that you may not have the desired grill marks on the meat with these mats. If you want the meat to look appetizing, make sure the grill gets hot enough then.

  • Heavy-duty mats
  • Reusable
  • Effortless cleanup
  • Grill marks missing

Verdict: An Aoocan set of five heavy-duty grill mats is enough to throw BBQ parties whenever you want.

How to Choose the Best Grill Mat

1. Size

This is definitely a no-brainer: the mat needs to fit your grill perfectly. Bring home a mat too small, and you will lose all the expected benefits from a high-quality grill mat. On the other hand, oversized mats can be narrowed down, of course, but why spend extra money for a bigger mat just to cut it down later?

Thus, do not forget to measure your grill carefully before choosing a suitable mat.

2. Non-stick Coating

best grill mat for gas grill

You certainly do not want the food to stick on the mat while grilling, right? That is why you need to take this factor into account when buying a new grill mat.

3. Temperature Capacity

As mentioned above, the maximum temp for the safe operation of a mat is 500 Fahrenheit degrees. Do not go any higher.

4. Thickness

Similar to other factors, you need something in between. Too thin mats may burn the food too fast while too thick ones distribute the heat unevenly.

Do you want an exact figure?

Well, I highly recommend 0.25mm as the optimal thickness for a decent mat.

5. PTFE Coating

Any grilling mat is coated with PTFE, but check whether it owns a single or a double coating. Of course, a double-coating mat comes at a higher price tag, but it is more efficient and durable. That is what I found when I tried both types at home.

6. Coefficient of Friction (COF)

the best bbq grill mat

Does it sound too scientific? Do not worry; think of it as the texture of the grill mat. Some have a smooth surface, while others come with a rough texture. So the question is, which one is better?

From my experience, I would prefer the smooth mat as it allowed effortless grilling and cleanup. The textured surface seemed to trap the tiny pieces of the food inside, which made maintenance more difficult.

How to Properly Maintain a Grill Mat

There are some things you must consider if you want your grill mat to last for a long time.

1. Avoid Using Utensils

The metal utensils can cause damages to your beloved mats. Therefore, go for silicone-tipped tongs or spatulas instead to maintain the mat for later uses.

2. Grill At Safe Temperature

best grill mat for composite decking

Remember the PTFE coating I mentioned above? According to the FDA, the maximum safe operating temp of using this resin is 500 Fahrenheit degrees. Once the heat exceeds this limit, the resin starts to melt and release toxic fumes.

We advise you to keep the temp in the 300-400 Fahrenheit degrees to avoid risking your health for a mere piece of meat.

3. Clean After Each Use

When the mat you ordered arrives, the first thing to do is to wash it with warm, water to get rid of any dust and dirt. After each use, hand-wash it immediately using a cloth and mild soap.

Do not apply anything abrasive on the mat or else it would ruin the non-stick coating and reduce the lifespan of your product. Stay away from scrubbing brushes or gritty soaps.

After cleaning, you had better keep it covered or store in a dry place. Check out the best grill covers here.

The Bottom Line

Now when you have fully understood the benefits of the grill mats, let’s refer to the article carefully and make a wise decision. All the products we introduced to you today are of high quality and covered with replacement or refund guarantee.

But the one that we find the best is Grillaholics Grill Mat. Why? As we mentioned it, it has unbeatable quality and is the only mat that is highly recommended by famous Chefs in the USA.

Grillaholics Grill Mat - Set of 2 Heavy Duty BBQ Grill Mats - Non Stick, Reusable, and Easy to Clean...*
  • THE #1 GRILL MAT FOR PRO GRILLERS! Did you know that our Grillaholics Set is the ONLY grill mat recommended by Rachael Ray and Chris Kimball for top resutls? It is the best value and quality in bbq...
  • SAY GOODBYE TO GRILLING MESSES… Now you never have to BBQ on a nasty, dirty grill grate again! Our heavy duty mat prevents your food from falling between the grates or sticking to your grill! Enjoy...
  • TESTED AS THE 100% PEFECT SIZE! Did you now that after running tons of tests, thicker mats does not mean better? We developed our grill mats to be thin enough to leave grill marks and robust flavor...
  • THE ULTIMATE GIFT FOR GRILLAHOLICS— Are you looking for the perfect gift for that special man or woman in your life? Our Grillaholics Non-Stick Grill Mats make great gifts for Father’s Day,...
  • SAFE FOR ALL OF YOUR GRILLING NEEDS! Our cooking mat works with any kind of barbecue grill— Weber, Charbroil, Big Green Egg, smoker, propane, gas, electric, or oven. These premium grill toppers are...

Honestly, you won’t make a mistake with any product from this list. Therefore, set your heart at rest while making an order.

Thank you for reading. Do not forget to like and share this article with any BBQ enthusiasts you know. Stay tuned for more posts!

Leave a Comment